ChnchemicalsGlobal Chemicals Intelligence← All stories

Plants & Capacity

South Korea: Shahin Variable Complicates Petrochemical Restructuring as Emission Reduction Targets Loom

7 min read
South Korea: Shahin Variable Complicates Petrochemical Restructuring as Emission Reduction Targets Loom

Key facts

  • The government and 10 petrochemical companies signed a voluntary agreement in August to reduce domestic NCC capacity by 2.7 to 3.7 million tons
  • S-Oil’s Shahin project in Ulsan is scheduled for completion next January, complicating the industry's restructuring efforts
  • SK Geo Centric, Korea Petrochemicals, and S-Oil have not yet agreed on their respective production reduction quotas
  • China’s expansion of ethylene facilities to increase self-sufficiency created a surplus in domestic Korean petrochemical capacity

The petrochemical industry is facing significant hurdles in its efforts to scale back production capacity.

Although 2.49 million tons of naphtha cracking complex (NCC) capacity in Dasan and Yeosu have been idled, the situation remains complicated by the completion of S-Oil’s Shahin project in Ulsan next January. Additionally, SK Geo Centric, Korea Petrochemicals, and S-Oil have yet to reach an agreement on their respective reduction quotas.

*News Rock* examines the current status of the industry’s restructuring, the impact of the Shahin startup, and the challenges facing the Ulsan reorganization.

The NCC restructuring in Dasan and Yeosu has proceeded smoothly.

According to the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, the government and 10 petrochemical companies signed a voluntary agreement last August to reduce domestic NCC production capacity by 2.7 to 3.7 million tons.

This measure was taken in response to China, the largest export market, expanding its ethylene facilities to increase self-sufficiency, which left domestic capacity in surplus.

The first approval was granted for the Dasan site. On February 23, the government approved the "Dasan Project No. 1," which involves splitting Lotte Chemical’s Dasan business unit and merging it with HD Hyundai Chemical.

The integrated entity, H&L Advanced, in which Lotte Chemical and HD Hyundai Oilbank hold equal stakes, was established in September. Consequently, Lotte Chemical’s 1.1 million-ton Dasan NCC will be idled for three years.

To support liquidity and technological development resulting from facility consolidation, the government has announced support measures worth over 2.1 trillion won.

Yeosu followed suit. On July 20, the government approved the business restructuring plans of Yecheon NCC, Lotte Chemical, Hanwha Solutions, and DL Chemical.

A combined 1.39 million tons of capacity—comprising 915,000 tons from Yecheon NCC’s Plant 2 and 470,000 tons from Plant 3—will be idled for the three-year restructuring period. Lotte Chemical’s Yeosu NCC will be integrated with Yecheon NCC.

The government will invest over 700 billion won in this project to fund research and development for high-value-added product conversion and provide tax incentives.

The total reduction from Dasan and Yeosu amounts to 2.49 million tons, representing 92% of the government’s minimum target.

On the 11th, Ulju County inspected the Shahin construction site to review ongoing issues and the status of building use approvals.

S-Oil expects to sequentially start up its polyethylene facilities, steam cracker, and total conversion to chemicals (TC2C) units from next January, with commercial operations anticipated to begin two to three months later, in March or April.

The Shahin project, located in the Onsan National Industrial Complex in Ulsan, involves an investment of 9.258 trillion won and has an ethylene capacity of 1.8 million tons. It utilizes TC2C technology to derive petrochemical feedstocks directly from crude oil.

The core issue is that the reduction and expansion phases are overlapping in timing.

Subtracting Shahin’s 1.8 million tons from the 2.49 million tons reduced in Dasan and Yeosu results in a net decrease in domestic ethylene production capacity of only approximately 690,000 tons.

More than 70% of the reduced capacity is being offset by new facilities, a dynamic that has fueled criticism that the restructuring is effectively a zero-sum game where one side’s cuts are neutralized by another’s expansion.

S-Oil approved its investment in the Shahin project in November 2022 and broke ground the following year. Because construction was already well advanced by the time the reduction agreement was reached in August of last year, industry observers argue that Shahin should have been factored into the baseline when the reduction targets were originally set.

Lee Deok-hwan, a professor emeritus of chemistry at Sogang University, noted that Shahin was slated for operation regardless of the restructuring discussions, and that significant construction progress had already been made by the time the industry began debating capacity cuts.

This perspective underscores the argument that reduction targets must be calculated based on the total installed capacity, including Shahin.

Professor Lee identified the approval stage for Shahin, rather than the restructuring process itself, as the critical point of concern.

He pointed out that the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy approved Shahin at a time when supply-demand imbalances linked to China were already emerging, expressing regret that the authorities did not exercise greater caution at that juncture.

The criticism centers on the fact that a large-scale expansion was pursued despite foreseeable overcapacity.

Disagreements over fairness in the burden-sharing remain unresolved. S-Oil maintains that because the purpose of the business restructuring is to phase out aging facilities, there is no need to include Shahin, a state-of-the-art plant, in the reduction discussions.

In contrast, SK Geo Centric and Daehan C&H, which are also based in Ulsan and must formulate their own restructuring plans, counter that excluding Shahin would disproportionately increase the reduction burden on existing operators.

SK Geo Centric reported operating losses for two consecutive years through last year, while Daehan C&H, whose core business is petrochemicals, lacks viable alternative operations to offset any capacity reductions.

The restructuring process in Ulsan, which must account for the remaining reduction targets, has made little progress in nearly a year.

SK Geo Centric, Daehan C&H, and S-Oil submitted a draft restructuring plan in December of last year but failed to reconcile differences over the specific reduction quotas for each company.

SK Innovation, the parent company of SK Geo Centric, stated in May that its goal is to finalize the plan within the year, but explained that discussions have been delayed by divergent stakeholder positions and uncertainties stemming from the geopolitical situation in the Middle East.

To meet the government’s reduction targets, an additional 210,000 to 1.21 million tons of capacity must be cut.

Only SK Geo Centric and Daehan C&H currently operate naphtha cracker (NCC) facilities in Ulsan, and their combined ethylene production capacity of 1.56 million tons is less than that of Shahin alone.

The government has maintained its principle of corporate autonomy. Moon Shin-hak, then First Vice Minister of the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, emphasized during the approval of the Yeosu restructuring plan in July that successful structural reform in the petrochemical industry requires business restructuring that involves all industrial complexes without free-riding.

The implementation of the Special Act on the Petrochemical Industry in April granted approved companies for business restructuring preferential treatment in licensing and permits, along with employment stability support.

However, because the legislation focuses primarily on support measures, there are no clear mechanisms to sanction companies if the restructuring process is delayed.

Critics argue that the evaluation criteria need to be redefined. In a September report titled "Structural Transformation of the Petrochemical Industry and Korea's Future Strategy," researcher Kim Eun-ah from the National Assembly Future Research Institute stated that the effectiveness of equipment rationalization policies should be assessed not by the reduction in NCC capacity, but by how much of the reduced capital, labor, and land has been transferred to new production structures. The report also proposed that the approval criteria for business restructuring plans must be made more specific.

Professor Lee noted, "Based on the progress to date, it appears that restructuring in Ulsan is impossible unless the government steps in to finalize the process." He explained that Ulsan has a diverse mix of facilities and companies with complexly intertwined interests, compounded by the presence of the Shahin project.

He added that while Daesan and Yeosu are part of larger conglomerates where other business units remain even if specific operations are scaled back, companies in Ulsan lack viable alternatives outside the petrochemical sector.

As a solution, Professor Lee suggested a model that acknowledges the operation of Shahin while distributing the resulting benefits.

He explained that demanding newly built large-scale facilities to lower their operating rates is unrealistic, as it would reduce overall efficiency.

He further proposed that since Shahin would capture the market share freed up by other companies' equipment reductions, it should be required to bear a portion of the social costs associated with the restructuring.

He emphasized that the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy is the only entity in a position to make such demands, urging the government to intervene more actively.

Chnchemicals take

The upcoming Shahin startup threatens to offset the intended capacity reductions, creating a structural imbalance that undermines the voluntary restructuring framework. Since the new facility will capture market share from idled units, regulators must enforce cost-sharing mechanisms to ensure fairness. This dynamic highlights the risk that new capacity additions can negate the benefits of supply-side adjustments in a globalized market.

Frequently asked questions

How does the completion of S-Oil's Shahin project affect the petrochemical restructuring in South Korea?

The Shahin project complicates the restructuring process by adding new capacity to the Ulsan cluster. Industry experts argue that the new plant may capture market share freed up by other companies' equipment reductions, undermining the intended supply reduction.

What is the current status of the naphtha cracking capacity reduction agreement in Dasan and Yeosu?

The government approved the first phase of the Dasan project, idling 2.49 million tons of naphtha cracking capacity. However, major companies including SK Geo Centric and Korea Petrochemicals have not yet agreed on their specific reduction quotas.

Why did the South Korean government initiate the voluntary agreement to reduce naphtha cracking capacity?

The agreement was signed in response to China expanding its ethylene facilities to increase self-sufficiency. This expansion left domestic Korean capacity in surplus, prompting the government and ten companies to agree to reduce production capacity by 2.7 to 3.7 million tons.